With or Without White People, “Black Lives Matter”

Here are the brute facts:

  • The African American male lives 5 years less than the average white American male.
  • 1 in every 15 African American men and 1 in every 36 Hispanic men are incarcerated in comparison to 1 in every 106 white men.
  • Unarmed black people were killed at 6x the rate of unarmed whites in 2015.
  • For every level of educational attainment, black Americans have unemployment rates that are similar to or higher than those of less educated white Americans.

According to Black Lives Matter founder Alicia Garza, this data reflects the reality of life for many black people living in America today. “When we say Black Lives Matter, we are talking about the ways in which Black people are deprived of our basic human rights and dignity. It is acknowledgement that Black poverty and genocide is state violence. It is an acknowledgement that 1 million Black people are locked in cages in this country-one half of all people in prisons or jails-is an act of state violence. It is an acknowledgement that Black women continue to bear the burden of a relentless assault on our children and our families and that assault is an act of state violence.”


As Garza makes clear, to believe that skin tone has anything to do with a person’s inherent right to life, liberty and pursuit of happiness is not only spiritually depraved and philosophically crooked, but it is also fundamentally unconstitutional. Furthermore, white people (men in particular) need to step up and acknowledge that “Black Lives Matter” is not just a rallying cry for a new civil rights movement, but a mantra which signifies the growth of a new consciousness which makes social justice a priority in the hearts and minds of blacks and whites alike.

That being said, replacing the words “Black Lives Matter” with “All Lives Matter” misses the point entirely. Sadly, white people have a long and undistinguished history of stealing from African American culture. From the Delta Blues to Hip Hop and from Cajun cooking to urban fashion, it is evident that many African American cultural traditions have been co-opted by whites for personal entertainment, commercial enterprise, and religious euphoria. Cecil Emeke once said, “Generally speaking, I think we live in a world that enjoys black culture and dislikes black people.”  What if America did love black people as much as black culture? March in Rochester

Moreover, to take the words “Black Lives Matter” and replace them with “All Lives Matter” is to participate in a terrible history of cultural theft and political silencing which has its most evil apparition in the industrialized slavery enterprises of the 19th century.  Likewise, to erase the words from Facebook posts, op-eds, and office whiteboards (e.g., the infamous case at Facebook’s headquarters) is to physically and symbolically say to a person of color, you don’t matter.  What you say does not matter. Your self expression does not matter. The pain and suffering behind those  “statistics” does not matter. This is a subtle yet pernicious form of white supremacy that if left unchecked will ultimately lead to the worst displays of hateful intolerance.

Indeed. What will it take to get white people to understand that the words “Black Lives Matter” does not in any way imply that white lives matter less. If I may speak out of place, I think the term was coined to show that merely acknowledging a person’s presence is a major part of the healing needed to address centuries of physical and emotional denigration and even enslavement. The words “Black Lives Matter” means see us. Don’t try to silence our voices and erase our feelings. We matter with or without you. See us for who we are. 

Regarding counter-phrases such as “White Lives Matter,” “Blue Lives Matter,” and “All Lives Matter,” Garza says that “to take blackness out of the equation is simply inappropriate.” Even President Obama, who has been a Conservative on race issues, remarked in a speech, “there is a specific problem that is happening in the African-American community that’s not happening in other communities.”

The President is absolutely  right: it’s called getting 5 years of your life ripped off just because you got the painted ping pong ball. It’s called getting locked up at a rate that quadruples other races because the system likes black bodies better than white ones. It’s called dying unarmed in the scopeIMG_20141012_162150 of a police officer’s rifle because they have an unwritten license to shoot first and ask questions later. It’s called injustice.

But in the end, why does anyone need permission to chant a phrase? What is truly behind the need to change these words into something they are not? Why can’t someone say what they want to say, especially if they are not engaging in violent hate speech or treasonous discourse? Why can’t “Black Lives Matter” be accepted as a form of constructive self empowerment, civil political action, and creative social purpose? Why does it have to be a threatening  insult to whites?

As a white American male living in the illusion of a post-racial democracy, I must admit that I do not have answers to these questions. But I do know that we must have this conversation out in the open. Only then can our human community finally come to the realization that what matters more than even color is communication. 







Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s